Politics and Social Change Workshop
Date and Time
Negating Citizenship: The Consequences of State Violence in Democracy for Victims
Speaker
Yanilda María González, Faculty Associate. Ford Foundation Associate Professor of Public Policy, Harvard Kennedy School.
Contact
Hannah Castner
hcastner@g.harvard.edu
Description
While the book, Rebuilding Citizenship After State Violence, examines the conditions under which victims’ families choose to undertake collective action to challenge democratic states after losing a loved one to police violence, this chapter first explores how the nature of engagement between victims and state institutions during families’ search for information, accountability, and redress can be highly consequential for victims, affecting them not only as individuals but as rights-bearing members of a polity. Neglect, obstruction, and mistreatment by democratic state institutions produce profound adverse effects that exacerbate the experience of victimization and impose further hardship on many aspects of victims’ lives. The chapter demonstrates how victimization by democratic states can become an ongoing process, producing enduring adverse effects that undermine the ability of victims’ families to pursue the basic social, economic, and political activities that are constitutive of citizenship in a democracy. To understand the distinctiveness of victimization at the hands of democratic states, the chapter first outlines a framework theorizing how two dimensions of victim-perpetrator relationships – the expectation of protection and embeddedness – shape the victimization experience and victims’ responses. The chapter goes on to discuss how the expectation of protection inherent in democratic states and the moderate degree of embeddedness of democratic states in citizens’ everyday lives compounds the experience of victimization. The framework is then illustrated with evidence from participatory action research alongside mothers of victims of police killings in Brazil and Colombia to describe the profound adverse effects of victimization at the hands of democratic states and the implications for citizenship. The chapter closes by discussing the flipside of democratic states’ moderate degree of embeddedness – the institutionalized forums of contestation that enable citizens to mobilize and challenge the state – and posing the book’s overarching research questions about the factors that lead victims’ families to respond to profound victimization at the hands of democratic state agents to pursue collective action, how they choose to mobilize, and the conditions under which their mobilization may have an impact.