Science, Technology, and Society Seminar: STS Circle at Harvard

Two-toned blue graphic background with the name of the seminar in white on top.

Date and Time

November 23, 2026
12:15PM - 02:00PM EST

Location

CGIS South, S354
A light lunch is provided for those that register by 1:00pm on the Thursday before the event.

Algorithms in Policy, Policy in Algorithms, Science in Both: Ecological Integration of the European Seas

Speaker

  • Przemyslaw Matt Lukacz, PhD Candidate, Department of the History of Science, Harvard University.

Chair

  • Sheila Jasanoff, Faculty Associate. Pforzheimer Professor of Science and Technology Studies; Professor of Environmental Science and Public Policy, Committee on Degrees in Environmental Science and Public Policy, Harvard Kennedy School.

Contact

Tenzin Dadak
tdadak@hks.harvard.edu

Abstract

This talk analyzes the interplay among policy regimes, developing scientific concepts, and digital technologies. It traces the relationship among the history of the concept of ecological coherence in marine policy in the European Union, the production of new environmental knowledge, and the logic of algorithmic optimization in conservation planning. Achieving ecological coherence across all conservation areas, both on land and at sea, has been a central objective of EU policy since the late 1970s. I trace how ecological coherence traveled from a vague legislative aspiration to becoming an object of ecological research to algorithmic operationalization in the governance of protected areas in the Baltic, North, and Mediterranean Seas. A widely held view in conservation planning is that algorithmic optimization may yield more certain morally and economically justifiable solutions. Yet despite substantial EU investment in marine science research, Europe's marine protected area network remains incoherent, and algorithmic analysis has largely stayed confined to "what-if" scenarios. These developments are best understood through the lens of experimentalist governance, a model of EU policymaking described by Charles Sabel and Jonathan Zeitlin, in which deliberately underdefined framework goals are filled in through locally devised strategies and metrics. Political scientists have largely left science and technology out of that picture. Recovering their place shows how new knowledge and technology produced to inform the meeting of EU objectives turn underspecified political goals into scientific standards. My analysis reveals a contrast between the apparent success of the EU’s funding ecosystem for transnational scientific consortia producing socially relevant knowledge and technology, and the checkered history of this knowledge’s diffusion into national governance regimes.

Bio

Matt Lukacz is a doctoral candidate in the History of Science at Harvard University. His dissertation, “The Divided Seas: Science, Algorithms, and Democratic Participation in the Global History of Marine Spatial Planning,” traces how algorithmic tools reshaped the politics of environmental governance and democratic participation in marine conservation. The dissertation focuses on case studies from Australia, the United States (specifically California), and the European Union. The project brings together environmental history, the global history of science, and critical studies of technology to understand how ideals of participation and transparency became entangled with the rise of algorithmic decision-making in biodiversity protection. Matt’s secondary interests include the intersection of the histories of social sciences and universities. Matt’s research has been supported by the National Science Foundation, the National Geographic Society, the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, and Harvard’s Graduate School of Arts and Sciences and the Weatherhead Center for International Affairs.

Valuing Accessibility

The Weatherhead Center for International Affairs welcomes individuals with disabilities to participate in its programs and activities. If you would like to request accommodations or have questions about the access provided, please get in touch with the person listed as the contact on the individual event listing in advance of your participation or visit. Requests for Sign Language interpreters and/or CART providers should be made at least two weeks in advance, if possible. Please note that the Weatherhead Center will make every effort to secure services, but that services are subject to availability.