From Ancien Régime to Capitalism: The French Revolution as a Natural Experiment
Publication information:
Robinson, James, Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, and Davide Cantoni. (March) 2007. “From Ancien Régime to Capitalism: The French Revolution As a Natural Experiment.”
Abstract
In this paper we exploit the invasion of Europe, particularly Germany, by French Revolutionary armies as a natural experimentto investigate the causal effect of the institutionsof the ancien régime on economic development. A central hypothesis which can account forcomparative development within Europe is that economic growth emerged
first in places whichearliest escaped ancien régime and feudal institutions. However, though there is a correlationbetween these two events, this does not demonstrate that it was the collapse of the ancien régime that caused the rise of capitalism. This is because there may be problems of reversecausation and omitted variable bias. We show how the institutional reforms (essentially theabolition of the ancien régime) brought by the French in Germany can be exploited to resolvethese problems. These reforms were akin to an exogenous change in institutions unrelatedto the underlying economic potential of the areas reformed. We can therefore compare theeconomic performance of the areas reformed to those not reformed before and after the Revolutionary period to examine the impact of the reforms. The evidence we present is consistentwith the hypothesis that the institutions of the ancien régime did indeed impede capitalism.